Why a Yellowstone mega-eruption would not wipe out humanity

The idea that a Yellowstone mega-eruption could wipe out humanity has long populated digital myths. A straightforward web tour can illustrate how such narratives spread. The notion of an end-of-the-world blast is persistent, but the question remains: would it truly end humankind?

Scientists note that a Yellowstone eruption would send far-reaching consequences across the globe and could even trigger a volcanic winter. The volcano is believed to awaken violently roughly every 600,000 years, with eruptions capable of tearing craters tens of kilometers wide. With the last major event dating back about 640,000 years, many people wonder when the next eruption might occur.

Yellowstone is classified as a supervolcano because its eruptions can exceed the output of typical volcanic activity by up to a hundredfold. This level of power makes it one of the most feared volcanic systems among geologists worldwide. Some warnings from international science bodies have imagined severe global effects, including prolonged famine caused by disrupted food supplies if crops fail for extended periods. The repercussions could be felt for decades, shaping climates and ecosystems for a long time.

Image of the Yellowstone volcano area ibitimes

Scientists point out that Yellowstone has erupted only a few times in the past two million years. “It will erupt again, but we don’t know when or how large,” says a volcanologist from the University of Leicester, underscoring the uncertainty that accompanies giant volcanic events.

Yet, when such an eruption occurs, the ash cloud could blanket large portions of the United States and Canada, making parts of North America largely uninhabitable. Simulations by multiple research teams suggest that anyone within about 1,000 kilometers would be in grave danger from the blast and the suffocating ash. The sun would be blocked, cooling global temperatures by as much as several degrees for years, altering ecosystems and weather patterns for generations.

A risky solution

NASA has explored ideas aimed at reducing the threat of a large-scale eruption. Brian Wilcox, a former member of NASA’s Planetary Defense Advisory Council, notes that the danger posed by a supervolcano can be greater than that from an asteroid or a comet. One proposed plan involves cooling the magma chamber by drilling into it and pumping water to absorb heat, potentially lowering the pressure that drives an eruption. That concept resembles creating a monumental power plant underground, but any attempt to puncture the magma pocket carries the risk of triggering an eruption or destabilizing the chamber. As a result, practical implementation is far from reality.

earthquakes in the region Yellowstone Volcano Observatory

The University of Utah has issued calm messaging, stating there are no signs of a catastrophic eruption at this time. They emphasize that Yellowstone is among the most closely monitored geological sites on the planet, with more than 40 seismic stations tracking ground movement around the clock.

No, humanity will not perish

Despite alarmist headlines, the Yellowstone Volcano Observatory has published an explanation of what a mega-eruption might mean in practical terms. The consensus is that humanity would not be extinguished, though the event would be devastating. The Observatory notes that the reality of these extreme eruptions is informed by past events where populations persisted through immense geological upheavals. The key takeaway is that, while severe, such eruptions would not spell the end of human existence simply because we have overcome much larger natural events in the distant past.

Scientists at the Observatory point to the last eruption around 631,000 years ago, a blast estimated to be ten times larger than the 1815 Tambora eruption in Indonesia and perhaps about one hundred times larger than Pinatubo in 1991. The scale was vast, and the damage undeniable, yet humanity endured in various regions. In much older events, such as Toba in Indonesia about 74,000 years ago and Taupo in New Zealand about 26,500 years ago, even larger explosions occurred before modern humanity existed, yet there is evidence that life persisted and adapted after the ash settled.

Tambora volcano crater POT

Archaeological data show that ancient populations did not vanish because of these colossal eruptions. Studies of early human activity across regions reveal resilience in the face of ash layers and disrupted climates. Still, such events left lasting changes in environments and ecosystems, shaping how early humans lived and migrated.

…

Environment department contact: [redacted]