Parade of red carpets is not always glamorous; some choices spark controversy and spark conversations about style, taste, and the risk of overstatement on stage. Even at top events, bold looks can clash with tradition, and the Oscar 2023 glow was no exception. Courage on the carpet is applauded, yet it can verge into extravagance. The following profiles highlight outfits that drew criticism for their fashion risk rather than polish.
Although a gala is a place for confidence and expression, these moments remind viewers that a bold statement can miss the mark. In the realm of black tie and semi formal attire, missteps are not rare. Here are some of the most talked about looks from the Oscar 2023 red carpet.
Florence Pugh
Florence Pugh appeared in a dramatic silhouette with pronounced volume. Critics noted the arm volume and the stark contrast with the shorts peeking beneath the dress, which some perceived as distracting rather than harmonious. The choice sparked debate about balance, proportion, and runway drama on a night of high fashion showcase.
Lenny Kravitz
Lenny Kravitz turned heads with a fearless, high impact ensemble where bold tailoring and hardware elements created a striking look. Some observers felt the balance between audacity and elegance was hard to strike, particularly in the fit of the trousers, which became a focal point of discussion on the carpet.
Melissa McCarthy
Melissa McCarthy chose a monochrome gown that aimed for sleek simplicity. The styling drew scrutiny for its fit and silhouette, with critics debating whether the design flatters the frame as intended. The moment sparked conversations about how color and cut interact on the stage lighting and red carpet energy.
Jessie Buckley
Jessie Buckley wore a whimsical dress with a bold shoulder structure. Some viewers felt the exaggerated shoulder silhouette overwhelmed the overall look, turning what could have been a playful moment into a theatrical statement that divided opinion on the night.
Rooney Mara
Rooney Mara chose a restrained dress that favored simple lines. While some admired the minimalist approach, others felt the garment did not translate to glamour on camera. The result sparked discussion about how simplicity performs under stage lights and in photographs from a major awards event.