Archaeologists studied the remains recovered from a well in Norwich, England, aiming to illuminate a dark chapter of medieval life. The analysis was published in Current Biology, adding to a growing body of evidence about how communities in 12th-century England lived, suffered, and were perceived by their contemporaries.
Historical records suggest that Jews began settling in England around the time of the Norman Conquest in 1066, following William the Conqueror and his new regime. The arrival of Jewish communities coincided with significant shifts in trade and commerce, and some residents believed that these newcomers could contribute to the country’s economic vitality. Yet, in contrast to the potential for mutual exchange, friction persisted. Some locals preserved distinct religious practices and customs, which at times fostered tension with broader society. A notorious account from 1144 reports the discovery of a mutilated Christian boy in Norwich, an event that local rumor attributed to ritual killings by Jews. Authorities intervened to prevent violence, but the episode reflected the broader climate of suspicion that existed in parts of medieval England during that era. Over the following century, episodes of violence against Jewish communities occurred across England, underscoring the precarious position of these minorities even as monarchs sought to balance toleration with public sentiment and security interests.
In 2004, Ian Barnes, a researcher at the Natural History Museum, led the examination of 17 individuals whose remains were recovered from the Norwich well. Stratigraphic analysis showed that these people were interred contemporaneously, suggesting a single, focused event rather than a sequence of burials. The abundance of children among the remains raised questions about the nature of the incident, with hypotheses ranging from an epidemic to a targeted massacre. To refine these possibilities, three new radiocarbon dates were obtained, enabling researchers to narrow the period of death to between roughly 1161 and 1216. From the set, six individuals were selected for genetic study. Among them, a teenage girl and two younger girls, aged five to ten and ten to fifteen, were identified as sisters sharing mitochondrial haplotype H5c2, while two other individuals showed more distant kinship. The data also revealed signs of inbreeding and certain genetic diseases across several genomes. Phenotypic inferences were possible for three people: two were described as having brown eyes, one with dark hair and the other with blond hair. A single boy, no older than three, displayed blue eyes and red hair. These genetic portraits contributed a human dimension to the historical record, illustrating how a small, interrelated group might have experienced life and loss in a tumultuous period.
By integrating the genetic findings with the known historical context, the researchers argued that the victims most plausibly belonged to Ashkenazi Jewish communities. When these results were compared with the well-documented pogrom that occurred on February 6, 1190, the team concluded that the Norwich victims were likely buried in the well as part of that tragic chain of events held within the broader European pattern of persecution during the late 12th century. This study adds a bioarchaeological perspective to the narrative of medieval anti-Jewish violence, highlighting how modern science can illuminate the human dimensions behind archival records and sensational rumors of the past. The narrative emphasizes the resilience and vulnerability of marginalized groups in medieval England, and it underscores the importance of careful interpretation when aligning archaeological findings with historical episodes [Citation: Norwich remains study, 2024].
ancient scientists solveWhy did the Egyptians choose the Giza plateau for the construction of the pyramids?