The initial reviews for Fantastic Beasts: A Dumbledore Mystery, arriving in cinemas on April 7, have started to appear online. The magical world’s latest trilogy installment has drawn a 47 score on Metacritic and a 58% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, signaling a mixed reception from critics.
Critics note that the screenplay has become clearer and more coherent, though it still carries a surplus of superfluous detail that can slow the storytelling. A number of assessments describe the plot as shapeless and shallow at moments, warning that some scenes feel unfocused. Yet the consensus remains positive on the film’s imaginative creatures, which many reviewers highlight as a bright, memorable aspect of the experience.
Special acknowledgment goes to Mads Mikkelsen for his portrayal of Gellert Grindelwald. The role, formerly filled by Johnny Depp, was reassigned after Depp exited the project following controversy involving his ex-wife. In Western media, critics often argue that Mikkelsen delivers a more nuanced, restrained villain than Depp, with some outlets noting that the performance subtly shifts the center of gravity within the film. For instance, Insider’s Kirsten Acuna comments that it is possible to forget the earlier casting altogether as the story unfolds, while The Telegraph’s Robbie Cullen suggests the Danish actor should have stepped into the role from the outset. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw characterizes Mikkelsen’s portrayal as more restrained and quietly menacing, a tonal shift that resonates with audiences seeking a subtler antagonist.
It is also noted that the movie will not screen in Russia, with discussions around access and distribution continuing in various markets. In the context of the global release, some readers have highlighted the ongoing debates about censorship and platform access. (VG Times)
Source: VG Times