When Mercedes-Benz revealed in the spring that it would phase out the manual transmission starting in 2023, readers in North America and beyond weighed in with mixed feelings. Some welcomed the shift toward modern automatics; others mourned the end of a tactile, hands-on driving experience that some enthusiasts equate with true sportiness.
For many drivers, the idea of mastering clutch pedals and precise gear changes feels awkward or tiring. Yet there are still those who consider manual gearboxes the purest expression of engaged, communicative driving. The debate, loud and lively, has evolved alongside torque-converter automatics and, more decisively, the rapid rise of dual-clutch transmissions. Since their adoption, these systems have transformed how quick and seamless gear changes can be, especially in compact cars that demand swift responses and crisp performance.
A dual-clutch transmission is an automated manual that can shift gears in an instant, either by automatic logic or via a rocker switch or lever. Because it eliminates the need for a clutch pedal, many observers simply describe it as an automatic while still acknowledging the engineered precision that comes from the dual-clutch mechanism. In practice, it offers the best of both worlds: the efficiency and direct feel of a manual, with the convenience of an automatic interface.
False judgments
Traditionally, many believed that a manual gearbox was not only sportier in practice—thanks to faster, more intentional shifts—but also more economical in fuel consumption. The common wisdom was that the mechanical setup could deliver better mileage, especially in city driving or on winding back roads.
Yet industry experts, including Peter Kerkrath of the maintenance and defect analysis organization KÜS, now say this assumption is outdated. He notes that automatic transmissions, particularly dual-clutch gearboxes, have surpassed manuals in efficiency. Dual-clutch systems can outperform even high-performance manuals when it comes to shift speed, which translates to better acceleration and smoother power delivery under many driving conditions.
Moreover, the historical gap in fuel consumption between manual and automatic configurations has narrowed dramatically. In many modern models, the difference is negligible, and in a number of cases the automatic setup achieves equal or superior fuel economy across a broad range of driving scenarios. As a result, the promotional pitch centered on “sportiness” alone loses some of its bite, according to Kerkrath. The pragmatic appeal increasingly centers on price and overall cost of ownership rather than mere driving thrills.
The affordability argument is a bit more nuanced. Historically, manually shifted cars often carried a lower sticker price due to simpler manufacturing, which translated into cheaper baseline models. Today that price gap has eroded as manufacturers confront tighter homologation, safety, and emissions standards, while consumers demand more features and refinement across the lineup. In many markets, price differentials between manual and automated options have become less pronounced, eroding the traditional edge of manual gearboxes on cost alone.
Industry observers also point to the broader push toward platform rationalization. With mass production and the need to test and certify numerous variants, automakers seek to standardize drivetrains to reduce development and homologation expenses. That strategic shift supports a leaner lineup with fewer manual offerings, and, as Britta Seegers, head of sales at Mercedes-Benz, explains, it reflects an effort to manage complexity and costs across global markets.
Not only money, but also a place
Beyond financial considerations, the move away from manual gearboxes frees up space inside the cabin. The center console trend favors compact, multifunctional layouts over bulky shifters. In many current designs, a simple, compact control or a small dial sits where a clunky lever once stood, complemented by modern conveniences like a cup holder, wireless charging pad, and a flexible storage niche. The net effect is a cleaner, more versatile interior that can better accommodate today’s tech-driven lifestyles and the needs of Canadian and American drivers alike.
Mercedes is not standing alone in these developments. A report in the German automotive press Automobilwoche indicates that Volkswagen is pursuing a similar strategy, aiming to reduce or even remove manual transmissions in the near term as part of a broader modernization plan for a new generation of vehicles slated for 2024. The trend underscores a shift across major brands toward transmissions that optimize efficiency, performance, and interior design—often at the expense of traditional manual gearboxes.
A picture: Depositphotos