A recent incident near Zamora deeply unsettled the local community. A 27-year-old woman was attacked by a group of dogs and did not survive. Residents express a shared fear that a similar event could happen to anyone, underscoring the need for clearer understanding of canine aggression and the role of environment in such incidents. Importantly, this tragedy shows that a dog’s breed does not reliably predict aggression.
Relating to
The rural roads around Roales del Pan, where the incident occurred, are common routes for grazing and hiking. The dogs involved were three mastiffs and two Leonese mastiffs, indigenous breeds with a history of guarding livestock. Spain houses more than nine million dogs, yet fatal dog attacks remain rare, with statistics showing only a couple of deaths per year attributed to dog aggression.
Common beliefs often link certain breeds such as the Dogue de Bordeaux or Rottweilers with greater aggression. The truth is that aggression in dogs is not determined solely by breed. In the past, even breeds considered docile have been involved in serious incidents.
Dog breeds: aggressive?
For example, in 2017 the Netherlands categorized 21 breeds as potentially dangerous, requiring owners to obtain licenses and training. But does breed truly define behavior? Training and socialization play crucial roles in a dog’s conduct. The Zamora case demonstrates that even dogs bred for shepherding can lash out unexpectedly.
Biologist Yolanda Cortés of the Biodiversity Foundation explained that biology does not follow strict mathematical rules and that there is a wide range of individual variability. Breeds like the Mastiff were selected for guarding livestock, yet this does not automatically translate into aggression toward people. Mastiffs often show protective instincts toward their families.
A 2022 study published in Science challenged the idea of fixed breed behaviors. Analyzing 2,000 dogs across 128 breeds and drawing on input from thousands of owners, the study found that only about 9% of behavioral differences were linked to breed, while roughly 25% could be explained by individual genetics. The takeaway is clear: environment and training contribute more to a dog’s behavior than heredity alone.
At the national level, some classifications label certain species as potentially dangerous. These debates question whether it is fair to judge an entire breed by the actions of a few individuals, suggesting a need for more nuanced approaches to animal welfare and public safety.
Join BİLGİ WhatsApp channel
INFORMATION
There are still factors that require careful examination in the Zamora incident, including how multiple breeds interact and how environmental influences shape behavior.
In summary, broad generalizations should be avoided. Attacks by dogs, while distressing and alarming, are uncommon. Breed does not solely determine behavior. Education, environment, and ongoing care are equally important. A deeper understanding of these elements can help prevent future incidents and foster a safer relationship between humans and dogs.