Having clear ideas is a hallmark of many restaurant experiences, and that clarity often starts on the very first impression. In this tale from the show First Dates, Eileen stands out as a 41-year-old chiropractor from Madrid who walks into the restaurant with a razor-sharp self-description. She declares herself brave, a warrior, and boldly progressive in everything she pursues. She notes that she has been more demanding than men lately, and while she is thriving at 41, she also carries a wealth of experience that shapes her expectations and choices on this particular date.
Carlos Sobera, the host, watches with curiosity as Eileen shares the type of person she hopes to meet during the visit. At the bar, she articulates a striking criterion for attraction: she wants a man who can make her feel chills from the very first moment, and she adds a practical caveat—she dislikes small stature in a partner. The candidness of her request sets the tone for a night that promises blunt honesty as much as it does potential connection.
In reply, the host invites Eileen to define herself more openly, prompting a playful back-and-forth that showcases her no-nonsense attitude. She responds with a sharp, unfiltered line that signals her preference for a certain physical presence, underscoring how straightforward she intends to be about what she desires. The moment is surprising, and it nudges the show into a space where humor mingles with frankness, leaving room for genuine reaction from everyone present.
Why Eileen has chosen such a direct approach becomes clear as she explains her reasoning: she wants to make the most of the years ahead. She does not ask for mere kindness or intelligence; she places emphasis on a presence that resonates with her energy. The preference for a certain physical dimension serves as a proxy for the kind of energy and chemistry she seeks, signaling a practical, experiential approach to dating rather than one grounded in abstract ideals.
As the evening progresses, Eileen meets David, a 46-year-old osteopath and acupuncturist from Madrid. The idea of meeting someone for a meaningful connection is evident, even when the conversation touches on the more provocative sides of desire. The show captures the tension between casual dating and the search for something deeper, acknowledging how difficult it can be to find love in a landscape filled with fleeting encounters.
When Eileen notices David, her first impression is candid and immediate. She comments on her own preferences, noting that she would have preferred a partner who was shorter, slimmer, and perhaps more athletic. Her honesty about personal preferences — including her note about not wanting children with this particular person — reveals the practical dimension of dating decisions that often goes unspoken on screen.
Eventually, the two settle into a space reserved for them at the restaurant, and their dialogue unfolds with the kind of raw openness that First Dates is known for. They take the opportunity to understand each other beyond surface impressions, acknowledging the difference between initial attraction and deeper compatibility. Eileen does not shy away from expressing her own self-perception, and she openly shares her opinions about David, even when they touch on personal identity traits in a forthright manner.
David responds with calm candor, explaining that his exploration of his sexuality is part of understanding his own hormonal responses from years past. He clarifies his orientation in a straightforward way, while Eileen continues to be forthright about her own fetishes and preferences. The exchange is direct and unembellished, reflecting the reality that dating conversations often traverse surprising and intimate terrain as people try to connect on multiple levels.
As the night draws to a close, a palpable tension shapes the finale. Neither participant feels ready to pursue a second date outside the restaurant. The air carries a sense that the match, while provocative in its early moments, may not translate into lasting interest. Eileen expresses a clear impression that David might lean toward men more than toward women, a conclusion that underscores how quickly impressions can form in the moment when personal disclosures are part of the conversation. The evening ends with both parties acknowledging the mismatch, closing the chapter on this particular encounter while leaving room for new possibilities elsewhere on the show.