Dozens of Unarmed Civilians Reported Shot Amid Gaza and West Bank Conflicts
The image widely circulated amid the ongoing war in Gaza and the broader escalation in the West Bank depicts unarmed people being hit by gunfire in public spaces. In the footage, civilians fall to the ground as others attempt to help, and snipers continue firing as responders approach. In some cases people try to pull others to safety using improvised means such as ropes or makeshift ladders. This sequence was described as taking place in Gaza City on December 31 in a report presented by Al Jazeera on a recent Sunday.
In the clip, a woman collapses, a clearly injured child trembles, and several men rush to assist. As they draw near, the shooter keeps firing. They throw cables and wood toward the child to help him grip and move to safety. The child is eventually removed from danger, and a man later carries the woman away. The scene captures the peril faced by bystanders and medical responders in dense urban settings.
[The images in this article may distress some readers]
Public reactions to such scenes have been strong across social media. One post described the mother being shot and a child severely wounded, calling on viewers to share the footage to raise global awareness. The message attributed to a Twitter user named Kerim Alastal appeared on February 11, 2024.
A 20-year-old medical student, Hadeel Haroun Abu al-Qara, reportedly died after being shot while accompanied by his cousin, Imad Hazem Abu al-Qara, who is four years younger. The family spoke to Agencia Sana and described the events near a local supermarket in Gaza. A separate account from witnesses and local media indicated that an Israeli sniper shot the pair while walking at Abu Iskandar intersection in Gaza City’s Sheikh Al Radwan area. Al Jazeera raised questions about the authenticity of the footage, while confirming that other verified clips show similar sniper actions.
The Israeli Defense Forces had not issued a formal response to inquiries about this case or similar incidents as the reporting continued. An analyst with a background in strategic studies, Rob Geist Pinfold from Durham University, suggested that changes in engagement rules have complicated the distinction between legitimate target zones and civilians, contributing to misidentifications in urban warfare. He noted that commanders may prioritize soldier protection, which can lead to higher risks for civilians during combat operations. The analyst emphasized that not all shootings in these scenes are justified and stressed the need for careful verification of each case.
The shift in doctrine, according to the analyst, was linked to the encounters involving remaining hostages who were freed or escaped. In some incidents, soldiers reportedly killed individuals who attempted to surrender or who had their hands raised with a white flag, raising concerns about adherence to international humanitarian laws during the conflict.
Officials publicly speaking on record in October spoke of broad, intensified actions in Gaza, with some leaders asserting the aim to regain control of the territory. Observers warn that the exchange of fire in densely populated areas increases risk to civilians and complicates military operations in urban environments.
Rising Complaints of Civilian Harm
Multiple reports indicate dozens of unarmed civilians have been shot in the course of the fighting. British broadcaster ITV recorded a moment in which a man carrying a white flag was shot, later identified as Ramzi Abu Sahlul in an interview segment.
On December 22, the Christian Patriarchate of Jerusalem condemned an attack in which two Palestinian women were killed during a sniper operation near the Holy Family Church in Gaza. After the October 7 onset of the conflict, Christian families had sought shelter at the church. The violence extended beyond Gaza into the West Bank, where on November 29 two children were reported killed during an Israeli Army raid in Jenin. The victims were Adam Samer al Ghoul, eight, and Basil Suleiman Abu al Wafa, fifteen. A video later verified by CNN showed an eight-year-old being shot in the street and dragged by a companion, leaving a trail of blood behind.
In late November, volatilities continued with reports of a nine-year-old Palestinian child being shot by Israeli forces in Jenin, raising questions about civilian safety in areas without Hamas presence. The overall death toll in the Gaza Strip has mounted amid ongoing operations, with United Nations figures indicating substantial casualties and mass displacement. An estimated 1.7 million people have sought shelter, many in Rafah near the Egyptian border or in improvised camps, as international observers call for accountability and adherence to humanitarian norms. Statements from regional leaders have underscored the seriousness of civilian harm and the need for protective measures in urban combat zones.
The broad picture reflects a painful chapter in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, underscoring the disparate risks faced by noncombatants, medical workers, and families caught in crossfire. International organizations continue to monitor the situation, urging restraint, independent investigations, and clear standards for engagement to minimize civilian suffering as the conflict persists in various cities and towns across the region.
As events unfold, observers emphasize that the human cost is measured not just in numbers but in the daily lives disrupted, the homes shattered, and the children whose futures are unsettled by a cycle of violence that has persisted for years.