What troubled the guests at the Park Avenue duplex party on January 14, 1970 was not the guest list, the menu, the music, or even the weather. The real issue involved Leonard Bernstein and Felicia Montealegre as they opened their home to friends amid a tense moment in American politics. Felicia, of Costa Rican descent and a founder of the women’s wing of the New York Civil Liberties Union, kept things refined by inviting Latino waitstaff and cooks. Yet the surrounding danger could not be contained, and the doorman, the elevator operator, or one of the crew might have been the threat that night. Outside, a different scene unfolded, with Black menial workers keeping watch in the district. For the couple, this would become a painful memory, a jarring counterpoint to the celebration honoring their work and influence in the arts and civil rights.
On February 2, 1969, a group of militants from the Black Panthers was arrested and faced trial on charges that included conspiracy to attack several targets in New York, including the New Haven Railroad, a police facility, and the Bronx Botanical Gardens. The bail set by the judge was so high that the Black Panthers called it a ransom, accusing the white judiciary of upholding oppression in plain sight. The procedure surrounding the detainees looked so unfair that Bernstein and his wife chose to act, drawing on their comfortable finances to raise funds for the cause by hosting a party for close friends. Among the attendees were prominent artists, directors, musicians, writers, journalists, and patrons who supported civil rights, cultural exchange, and political change. The guest list included notable figures from theatre, film, music, and journalism, all invited to contribute to the larger conversation about justice and equality.
“I grew up in France during the rise of Nazism, and I have always believed that justice is the only thing worth supporting,” remarked the wife of a public official who helped protect parks and culture in New York. She contributed a substantial amount, though it was a touch lower than some other guests, reflecting a personal stance that generosity should accompany civic engagement. The contributions from Otto Preminger, Sheldon Harnick, Burton Lane, Julie Belafonte, and an anonymous donor added momentum to the effort. The total raised approached ten thousand dollars, ensuring the event would have a meaningful impact while sustaining the evening’s hopeful energy, despite an undercurrent of tension among guests.
black maoism
“If companies won’t hire fully, we may have to take control of the means of production to serve the people,” declared Donald Cox, a Black Panthers leader who used the party to articulate the group’s goals. He spoke about breakfast programs for underprivileged children, reforms in education to include Black history and culture, the creation of hospital networks for Black communities, and direct action when needed. Remembering Fred Hampton, a Black Panther leader killed by police in Chicago the previous year, Cox warned that violence could follow if homes and beds were attacked. The mood was fierce, his message clear: self-defense was a necessity in the face of oppression.
Some guests appreciated the principled stance, including Bernstein, who publicly supported the sentiment. Others grew uneasy. A wife of a prominent businessman asked if she might be targeted next, but the response from Lee Berry, whose husband was one of the detainees, reassured the crowd: fear was not the plan. Berry and others from a wealthy circle offered counsel and defense, yet the dynamic proved delicate. A member of the Metropolitan Museum staff, Cynthia Phipps, echoed the sentiment that big-city privilege did not guarantee safety or silence when injustice pressed in from every side.
Ray Masai Hewitt, the Black Panthers’ Education Minister, asserted a stark stance: while some of the guests might hold sympathy for the system, the Panthers did not. They sought revolutionary change and would fight to the end. The discussion underscored a broad debate about strategy, dignity, and the necessary means to achieve a more equitable society.
Despite extensive media attention, Bernstein and Montealegre faced pressure from authorities who disagreed with their stance. In 1980 Bernstein revealed declassified documents suggesting the FBI had conducted a smear campaign against the couple in retaliation for their outspoken civil rights advocacy. Anonymous letters circulated, insinuations appeared in editorials, and some outlets lampooned their efforts as radical chic. Yet the couple continued to see the event as a milestone in civil rights advocacy, a moment when art and politics intersected in the fight for justice.
Tom Wolfe’s report, later titled in translation as Delicious Left or Yummy Left, chronicled the night extensively. The journalist recounted conversations with guests and observers, offering a vivid portrait that sparked debate about media ethics, power, and the culture of radicals. Wolfe’s dramatic account became famous for its detailed dialogue and the sense that the party, for all its glamour, revealed deeper tensions within American society. The night became famous for its candid, sometimes chaotic, exchange of ideas and its enduring impact on how artists and intellectuals were viewed within political movements.